Score: 8

"Funny Idea"

submission: Coke Goldberg Machine

date: January 2, 2009

It's a funny idea with good timing and good use of sound.

Score: 8

"How pleasing"

submission: Chad Punches Old Ladies

date: January 2, 2009

I was entertained!

Score: 6

"Cool character art."

submission: Death & screams

date: June 1, 2005

You did a great job with the character art, especially for death. Some of the enviornments could have been a bit more developed, but given the time you finished in, they came out very well. I thought the music and sound worked well the animation. Nicely done.

Score: 7

"Nice Presentation"

submission: Malaria

date: June 1, 2005

Great use of visual effects on the text and the still images. The music also set an appropriately urgent tone. The font was a bit difficult to read on some of the screens, and there were places where spell check would have helped. Overall though, great job. I'm sure this will go over really well. It would be cool if there were a bit more interactivity for the stand-alone presentation on this site. But, as it stands it gets the message across effectively.

Score: 4

"Ooky and spooky."

submission: !Nightmare!

date: December 15, 2002

Great song, a decent video for it. The sync is cool, if the art were cleaned up a little and perhaps a little more subtle I think you'd have a great movie. The machinery and scan lines were nice touches and there's some great detail. A little heavy handed, but it would be good for around halloween.

Score: 8

"A welcome return of a green menace."

submission: Kermit Kombat 2 ep2

date: December 15, 2002

Super useful scene selector and dress up preloader are great interactive additions to the movie. the miss cleo stuff was hysterical as was the megaman scene and the muppet bits. I was less smitten with the kung fu bits, but letting you name the dingus was another masterstroke. Well done. I waited for the episode on a 56K and I'm glad I did.

Score: 7

"A Monkey! Well, color me pleased."

submission: Bureau of Justice Trailer

date: December 12, 2002

It looks like it could shape up to be a funny super hero romp. A cameo by George the Owl would make this cartoon hard to beat. George the Owl lends a quiet dignity and hilarity to any situation. Oh that owl!

Score: 3

"Neat Montage"

submission: Samus and the Metroid

date: December 12, 2002

A cool tribute to samus, well cut together with the super metroid theme. Intercutting samus with the metroid is interesting, maybe more could be done with that. This could shape up into a cool music video.

Score: 9

"Funny stuff with fluffy beast"

submission: S. Sheep & The Sea-Saw

date: December 12, 2002

Great physical comedy with a simple premise and terrific art, style, and timing to boot. Short and silly, a great little joke. Thanks so much.

Score: 7

"Its like a polynesian cocktail of delightment"

submission: Dancing Tiki Men

date: December 12, 2002

The art in dancing tiki men is great. No story per se. But what can you do. The story of the dancing tiki men may not be so epic as to capture in flash, but the dance itself, ah the dance, that is where the tiki men come through with aplomb. I hope you work on longer flash cartoons using the same graphic style. It's quite good and shows a great understanding of keeping file sizes down. Maestro, I say "right on".